1999: Anaheim  defeat San Francisco  (4-3)
2000: San Francisco  defeat Anaheim  (4-2)
2001: Minnesota  defeat San Francisco  (4-1)
2002: Florida  defeat Cleveland  (4-0)
2003: Atlanta  defeat Minnesota  (4-3)
2004: Toronto  defeat Atlanta  (4-3)
2005: Atlanta  defeat Minnesota  (4-2)
2006: Minnesota  defeat Florida  (4-2)
2007: Toronto  defeat Milwaukee Brew (4-2)
2008: Los Angeles  defeat Anaheim  (4-3)
2009: Florida  defeat Toronto  (4-3)
2010: Milwaukee Brew defeat Oakland  (4-1)
2011: Milwaukee Brew defeat Kansas City  (4-1)
2012: New York (A)  defeat Milwaukee Brew (4-1)
2013: Chicago (A)  defeat San Francisco  (4-1)
2014: Seattle  defeat Milwaukee Brew (4-2)
2015: Toronto  defeat Florida  (4-3)
2016: Chicago (N)  defeat Seattle  (4-0)
2017: San Francisco  defeat Boston  (4-0)

 P Danny Darwin (ANA) eligible 2005, elected 2005
RF Tony Gwynn (HOU) eligible 2006, elected 2006
2B Tony Fernandez (BAL) eligible 2005, elected 2007
 P Orel Hershiser (ANA) eligible 2005, elected 2008
 P Dennis Eckersley (CHN) eligible 2006, elected 2008
 P Roger Clemens (NYA) eligible 2007, elected 2008
 P Mike Morgan (OAK) eligible 2006, elected 2009
LF Barry Bonds (KC) eligible 2009, elected 2009
 P Randy Myers (HOU) eligible 2005, elected 2010
LF Jose Canseco (BAL) eligible 2009, elected 2010
RF Paul O'Neill (SEA) eligible 2010, elected 2010
1B Mark McGwire (WIS) eligible 2011, elected 2011
LF Albert Belle (SF) eligible 2011, elected 2011
 P Randy Johnson (FLA) eligible 2011, elected 2011
 P Greg Maddux (MIN) eligible 2012, elected 2012
3B Matt Williams (ATL) eligible 2012, elected 2013
CF Larry Walker (OAK) eligible 2013, elected 2013
2B Craig Biggio (FLA) eligible 2013, elected 2014
RF Sammy Sosa (ANA) eligible 2013, elected 2014
2B Roberto Alomar (ANA) eligible 2015, elected 2015
 P Curt Schilling (FLA) eligible 2016, elected 2016
1B Andres Galarraga (BOS) eligible 2010, elected 2017
 P Kevin Brown (CIN) eligible 2011, elected 2017
3B Vinny Castilla (WIS) eligible 2015, elected 2017
1B Jim Thome (ATL) eligible 2016, elected 2017
SS Walt Weiss (ANA) eligible 2009, elected 2018
 P Todd Stottlemyre (BRE) eligible 2012, elected 2018
 P John Smoltz (TOR) eligible 2013, elected 2018
RF Gary Sheffield (WIS) eligible 2015, elected 2018

 P Jimmy Key (CIN) eligible 2006
 P Chuck Finley (SEA) eligible 2007
 P Jamie Moyer (ANA) eligible 2007
 P Mark Gardner (NYN) eligible 2007
 P Al Leiter (CHA) eligible 2009
 C Darrin Fletcher (FREE) eligible 2011
 P David Cone (DET) eligible 2011
1B Will Clark (DET) eligible 2011
CF Brady Anderson (TEX) eligible 2011
CF Marquis Grissom (FREE) eligible 2011
 P Andy Ashby (SF) eligible 2012
 P John Wetteland (SD) eligible 2012
LF Greg Vaughn (CIN) eligible 2012
1B Rafael Palmeiro (PHI) eligible 2012
 P Darryl Kile (MIN) eligible 2012
 P Denny Neagle (SEA) eligible 2013
 P Ramon Martinez (SD) eligible 2014
2B Jose Offerman (MIN) eligible 2014
 P Jeff Juden (ATL) eligible 2015
1B John Olerud (WIS) eligible 2015
CF Jim Edmonds (CHA) eligible 2015
 P Scott Erickson (MON) eligible 2015
 P Rick Helling (BRE) eligible 2015
CF Bernie Williams (TOR) eligible 2016
 P Mike Mussina (FLA) eligible 2016
 P Brad Radke (ATL) eligible 2016
 P Kevin Appier (TOR) eligible 2016
 P Alan Benes (ATL) eligible 2016
2B Delino DeShields (BOS) eligible 2016
CF Raul Mondesi (BRE) eligible 2016
 P Dustin Hermanson (ANA) eligible 2016
 P Wilson Alvarez (ANA) eligible 2016
LF Bobby Higginson (PIT) eligible 2016
 P Mike Hampton (COL) eligible 2016
 P Mike Sirotka (STL) eligible 2016
RF Juan Gonzalez (PHI) eligible 2017
 C Mike Piazza (ATL) eligible 2017
 P Shane Reynolds (MIN) eligible 2017
RF Shawn Green (CHA) eligible 2017
1B Mo Vaughn (ANA) eligible 2017
 P Jon Lieber (MIN) eligible 2017
 P Omar Daal (NYA) eligible 2017
 P Pedro Astacio (BOS) eligible 2017
 P Steve Trachsel (CHN) eligible 2017
3B Chipper Jones (CLE) eligible 2018
RF Manny Ramirez (ATL) eligible 2018
 P Arthur Rhodes (CIN) eligible 2018
SS Alex Gonzalez (MON) eligible 2018
 P Alex Fernandez (SD) eligible 2018
 P Hideki Irabu (OAK) eligible 2018
 P Carlos Perez (CHA) eligible 2018
 P Joey Hamilton (COL) eligible 2018
 P Ron Blazier (BAL) eligible 2018
 P Matt Morris (ANA) eligible 2018
 C Ivan Rodriguez (ATL) eligible 2019
CF Ken Griffey Jr. (PHI) eligible 2019
 C Jorge Posada (CHA) eligible 2019
 P Ramiro Mendoza (CHA) eligible 2019
 P Brian Anderson (BAL) eligible 2019
 P Jason Schmidt (STL) eligible 2019
 P Pedro J. Martinez (TB) eligible 2020
SS Nomar Garciaparra (COL) eligible 2020
RF Vladimir Guerrero (LA) eligible 2020
LF Darin Erstad (ANA) eligible 2020
 P Andy Pettitte (KC) eligible 2020
 P Jimmy Haynes (PIT) eligible 2020
 P Jose Rosado (CHN) eligible 2020
 P Jaret Wright (KC) eligible 2020
SS Edgar Renteria (SF) eligible 2021
 P Kevin Millwood (PHI) eligible 2021
CF Rondell White (CIN) eligible 2021
 P Jose Lima (SEA) eligible 2021
SS Placido Polanco (BAL) eligible 2021
SS Derek Jeter (DET) eligible 2022
 C Jason Kendall (SF) eligible 2022
 P Bartolo Colon (BRE) eligible 2022
SS Mike Caruso (NYN) eligible 2022
 P Dennis Reyes (BRE) eligible 2022
 P Kelvim Escobar (TOR) eligible 2022
 C Frank *Wolverton (PIT) eligible 2022
 P Chris Carpenter (MON) eligible 2022
 P Jeff D'Amico (LA) eligible 2022
SS Sandy Maldondo (ATL) eligible 2022
2B Marshall McDougal (DET) eligible 2022
 C Jeff Pezold (SD) eligible 2022
SS Alex Rodriguez (MIN) eligible 2023
SS Neifi Perez (DET) eligible 2023
3B Aramis Ramirez (MIN) eligible 2023
CF Andruw Jones (ATL) eligible 2023
 P Shawn Estes (COL) eligible 2023
 P Kerry Wood (TOR) eligible 2023
 P Ted Lilly (ATL) eligible 2023
3B Adrian Beltre (TOR) eligible 2023
 C Icicle Bouton (TOR) eligible 2023
 P Carl Pavano (TEX) eligible 2023
 P Jason Grilli (MON) eligible 2023
SS Miguel Tejada (NYN) eligible 2023

1999: Matt Williams (3B), ATL (.320 AVG, 42 HR, 112 RBI)
2000: Matt Williams (3B), ATL (.328 AVG, 48 HR, 137 RBI)
2001: Derek Jeter (SS), SF (.340 AVG, 41 HR, 94 RBI)
2002: Derek Jeter (SS), SF (.351 AVG, 30 HR, 76 RBI)
2003: Ken Griffey Jr. (CF), ATL (.314 AVG, 75 HR, 171 RBI)
2004: Nomar Garciaparra (SS), FLA (.359 AVG, 40 HR, 119 RBI)
2005: Manny Ramirez (RF), ATL (.354 AVG, 67 HR, 172 RBI)
2006: Manny Ramirez (RF), ATL (.281 AVG, 35 HR, 90 RBI)
2007: Nomar Garciaparra (SS), FLA (.295 AVG, 34 HR, 81 RBI)
2008: Jim Early (2B), BRE (.322 AVG, 60 HR, 121 RBI)
2009: Raul Mondesi (CF), BRE (.326 AVG, 37 HR, 101 RBI)
2010: Ray Burrus (SS), PHI (.347 AVG, 35 HR, 76 RBI)
2011: Tucker Concepcion (2B), PHI (.375 AVG, 42 HR, 107 RBI)
2012: Jim Early (2B), BRE (.336 AVG, 37 HR, 91 RBI)
2013: Kevin Punn (SS), CIN (.384 AVG, 46 HR, 117 RBI)
2014: Allan Bass (SS), PIT (.330 AVG, 44 HR, 100 RBI)
2015: Mick Bell (LF), FLA (.342 AVG, 54 HR, 138 RBI)
2016: Heinie Gainer (RF), FLA (.329 AVG, 32 HR, 97 RBI)
2017: Allan Bass (SS), PIT (.333 AVG, 63 HR, 126 RBI)

1999: Jeromy Burnitz (LF), BAL (.330 AVG, 46 HR, 134 RBI)
2000: Sammy Sosa (RF), ANA (.349 AVG, 54 HR, 163 RBI)
2001: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.359 AVG, 50 HR, 160 RBI)
2002: Ben Grieve (RF), MIN (.360 AVG, 57 HR, 190 RBI)
2003: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.353 AVG, 45 HR, 176 RBI)
2004: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.359 AVG, 47 HR, 184 RBI)
2005: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.373 AVG, 59 HR, 163 RBI)
2006: Edgar Renteria (SS), TOR (.319 AVG, 27 HR, 89 RBI)
2007: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.335 AVG, 35 HR, 88 RBI)
2008: Chief Moschitto (SS), TOR (.333 AVG, 48 HR, 128 RBI)
2009: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.328 AVG, 37 HR, 102 RBI)
2010: Chief Moschitto (SS), TOR (.379 AVG, 46 HR, 118 RBI)
2011: Chief Moschitto (SS), TOR (.341 AVG, 47 HR, 95 RBI)
2012: Scott Tyler (2B), TEX (.351 AVG, 57 HR, 127 RBI)
2013: Hugh Vaughn (SS), CHA (.342 AVG, 44 HR, 107 RBI)
2014: Steve Fonseca (SS), SEA (.372 AVG, 63 HR, 116 RBI)
2015: Steve Fonseca (SS), SEA (.353 AVG, 53 HR, 106 RBI)
2016: Art Wilkinson (2B), SEA (.356 AVG, 66 HR, 136 RBI)
2017: Hugh Vaughn (SS), CHA (.343 AVG, 54 HR, 127 RBI)

1999: Bartolo Colon, (P, HOU) (21-6, 2.01 ERA, 335 K's)
2000: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, SF) (29-3, 1.54 ERA, 438 K's)
2001: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, SF) (33-3, 1.61 ERA, 423 K's)
2002: Jeff Juden, (P, ATL) (25-5, 2.12 ERA, 320 K's)
2003: Brad Radke, (P, ATL) (30-3, 2.39 ERA, 372 K's)
2004: Alan Benes, (P, ATL) (31-2, 2.37 ERA, 334 K's)
2005: Brad Radke, (P, ATL) (28-5, 3.25 ERA, 318 K's)
2006: Brad Radke, (P, ATL) (24-7, 1.79 ERA, 348 K's)
2007: Bill Malinosky, (P, LA) (22-6, 1.57 ERA, 270 K's)
2008: Bill Malinosky, (P, LA) (23-4, 2.08 ERA, 274 K's)
2009: Jason Schmidt, (P, STL) (20-8, 2.38 ERA, 272 K's)
2010: Bartolo Colon, (P, BRE) (19-7, 1.27 ERA, 282 K's)
2011: Ryan Mills, (P, PHI) (20-9, 2.75 ERA, 208 K's)
2012: Bill Malinosky, (P, LA) (23-5, 1.49 ERA, 246 K's)
2013: Bob Bonds, (P, FLA) (23-7, 1.99 ERA, 268 K's)
2014: Bill Malinosky, (P, LA) (23-3, 1.66 ERA, 246 K's)
2015: Bartolo Colon, (P, BRE) (20-7, 1.50 ERA, 195 K's)
2016: Bill Malinosky, (P, LA) (20-11, 2.82 ERA, 271 K's)
2017: Ricky Bradley, (P, SF) (23-7, 1.95 ERA, 230 K's)

1999: Greg Maddux, (P, OAK) (27-7, 2.12 ERA, 341 K's)
2000: Orlando Hernandez, (P, ANA) (24-8, 2.28 ERA, 329 K's)
2001: Greg Maddux, (P, MIN) (29-6, 2.38 ERA, 409 K's)
2002: Greg Maddux, (P, MIN) (24-5, 2.03 ERA, 376 K's)
2003: Greg Maddux, (P, MIN) (30-7, 2.60 ERA, 416 K's)
2004: Kerry Wood, (P, TOR) (24-3, 2.00 ERA, 331 K's)
2005: Greg Maddux, (P, MIN) (29-5, 2.63 ERA, 365 K's)
2006: Jose Lima, (P, WIS) (23-9, 2.08 ERA, 284 K's)
2007: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, SEA) (20-7, 1.63 ERA, 344 K's)
2008: Ramiro Mendoza, (P, CHA) (23-10, 1.71 ERA, 248 K's)
2009: Ramiro Mendoza, (P, CHA) (23-5, 1.93 ERA, 229 K's)
2010: Kelvim Escobar, (P, TOR) (19-8, 2.11 ERA, 263 K's)
2011: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, TB) (27-6, 2.24 ERA, 335 K's)
2012: Bob Ainsmith, (P, DET) (23-13, 2.42 ERA, 278 K's)
2013: Kerry Wood, (P, TOR) (25-6, 2.86 ERA, 251 K's)
2014: Kelvim Escobar, (P, TOR) (24-7, 2.57 ERA, 253 K's)
2015: Kerry Wood, (P, TOR) (23-4, 2.14 ERA, 187 K's)
2016: Don Reed, (P, SEA) (22-6, 2.56 ERA, 256 K's)
2017: Taylor Rohr, (P, CHA) (27-6, 2.49 ERA, 228 K's)

1999: Eric *Milton, (P, ATL) (20-9, 3.15 ERA, 241 K's)
2000: George *Hutcheson (C), PIT (.260 AVG, 18 HR, 50 RBI)
2001: Ty *Cobb Jr (LF), FLA (.316 AVG, 16 HR, 57 RBI)
2002: Frank *Chase (1B), PIT (.278 AVG, 27 HR, 62 RBI)
2003: Ray *Roach (2B), CHN (.334 AVG, 16 HR, 47 RBI)
2004: Chick Brodie (1B), CIN (.325 AVG, 21 HR, 75 RBI)
2005: Tony Delis (C), CHN (.380 AVG, 18 HR, 52 RBI)
2006: Mariano *Ryal (3B), COL (.254 AVG, 13 HR, 32 RBI)
2007: Carlos Stueland, (P, PIT) (5-8, 7.27 ERA, 39 K's)
2008: Chris *Gladu (1B), ATL (.198 AVG, 8 HR, 18 RBI)
2009: George Alomar (2B), STL (.281 AVG, 20 HR, 38 RBI)
2010: Duante May (1B), CHN (.389 AVG, 0 HR, 5 RBI)
2011: Greg Jones (1B), CIN (.354 AVG, 17 HR, 56 RBI)
2012: MArk Teixeira (3B), SF (.245 AVG, 20 HR, 42 RBI)
2013: Martin *Sanchez, (P, CIN) (0-2, 6.61 ERA, 10 K's)
2014: Dave Parker (RF), CIN (.333 AVG, 25 HR, 62 RBI)
2015: Don Suttton, (P, CIN) (9-10, 3.80 ERA, 102 K's)
2016: Ryan Sandberg (2B), CHN (.293 AVG, 14 HR, 35 RBI)
2017: Alex Cora (SS), COL (.301 AVG, 20 HR, 42 RBI)

1999: Orlando *Hernandez, (P, ANA) (20-3, 2.14 ERA, 236 K's)
2000: Eric *Munson (C), CHA (.327 AVG, 12 HR, 49 RBI)
2001: Shane *Monahan (RF), TOR (.267 AVG, 18 HR, 53 RBI)
2002: Rex *Konetchy (C), MIN (.278 AVG, 19 HR, 69 RBI)
2003: Angelo *Franco (CF), OAK (.313 AVG, 25 HR, 87 RBI)
2004: Rodney *Lindsey (CF), BOS (.243 AVG, 4 HR, 39 RBI)
2005: Mark *Nichols (SS), DET (.265 AVG, 15 HR, 44 RBI)
2006: Alex *Sanchez (LF), TOR (.259 AVG, 23 HR, 72 RBI)
2007: Johnnie *Hernandez (SS), NYA (.254 AVG, 24 HR, 61 RBI)
2008: Al *Ball (1B), MIN (.274 AVG, 22 HR, 53 RBI)
2009: Dan Gessler, (P, NYA) (5-14, 4.15 ERA, 104 K's)
2010: Jack Bair (3B), OAK (.248 AVG, 19 HR, 42 RBI)
2011: Chris Mattick (3B), ANA (.294 AVG, 20 HR, 43 RBI)
2012: Todd Linden (CF), TEX (.317 AVG, 24 HR, 38 RBI)
2013: Vance *Sanders (SS), CLE (.188 AVG, 5 HR, 12 RBI)
2014: Steve Garvey (1B), ANA (.304 AVG, 22 HR, 53 RBI)
2015: Mickey Mantle (CF), ANA (.268 AVG, 19 HR, 40 RBI)
2016: Case Miller (RF), MIN (.317 AVG, 16 HR, 46 RBI)
2017: Hardin Foley (SS), KC (.297 AVG, 30 HR, 76 RBI)

No awards given for this catagory.

2010: Chief Moschitto (SS, TOR) (.379, 46, 118)